A DMV administrative hearing is your opportunity to fight for your driving privileges. Unlike a criminal trial, there is no jury. The hearing officer serves as both judge and prosecutor, making preparation absolutely critical. After handling thousands of these hearings, I have developed a comprehensive checklist that covers everything you need to be ready.
Phase 1: Immediate Actions (Days 1‑10)
- Request the hearing within 10 days: This is non‑negotiable. Call the DMV Driver Safety Office or have your attorney make the request. Get a confirmation number.
- Hire a DMV defense attorney: Do this as early as possible. Your attorney needs time to investigate and prepare.
- Write down everything you remember: Document every detail of the incident while your memory is fresh. Include times, locations, what you consumed, officer interactions, and test procedures.
- Preserve evidence: If there were witnesses, get their contact information. If there was surveillance footage nearby, request it before it is overwritten.
Phase 2: Evidence Gathering (Days 10‑30)
- Obtain the police report: Your attorney can request this through a discovery process. Review it carefully for inaccuracies.
- Request breathalyzer maintenance records: The device used to test you must be properly calibrated and maintained. Gaps in maintenance records can be grounds for challenging the results.
- Get the officer's training records: Verify that the arresting officer was properly trained in field sobriety test administration and breathalyzer operation.
- Obtain dashcam and bodycam footage: Many departments now record traffic stops. This footage can reveal procedural errors or contradict the officer's report.
- Gather medical records: If you have any medical conditions that could affect field sobriety test performance or breath test results, get documentation from your physician.
- Identify expert witnesses: Depending on your case, you may need a toxicologist, a breathalyzer expert, or a field sobriety test specialist.
Phase 3: Case Analysis and Strategy
With your evidence gathered, your attorney should conduct a thorough analysis of the DMV's case against you. The DMV must prove three things at an APS hearing:
- The officer had reasonable cause to believe you were driving under the influence
- You were lawfully arrested
- You were driving with a BAC of 0.08% or higher (or 0.04% for commercial drivers, or 0.01% for drivers under 21)
Your defense strategy should target the weakest link in this chain. If the officer lacked reasonable cause for the stop, the entire case may fall apart. If the arrest was procedurally flawed, the test results may be inadmissible. If the test itself was unreliable, the BAC evidence can be challenged.
Phase 4: Hearing Day Preparation
- Organize your evidence: Prepare copies of all exhibits, clearly labeled and in logical order
- Prepare your testimony: If you plan to testify, practice with your attorney. Know what questions to expect and how to answer them clearly and concisely.
- Prepare cross‑examination questions: Your attorney should have a detailed list of questions for the arresting officer, targeting the weaknesses identified in the case analysis.
- Review the hearing procedures: Understand the format of the hearing, the order of presentation, and the rules of evidence that apply.
- Dress professionally: First impressions matter. Dress as you would for a job interview.
- Arrive early: Give yourself plenty of time to get settled and review your materials one last time.
Phase 5: At the Hearing
During the hearing itself, keep these principles in mind:
- Be respectful: Address the hearing officer professionally and remain calm, even if the proceedings become adversarial.
- Listen carefully: Pay close attention to the officer's questions and the officer's testimony. Take notes on anything that contradicts the written report.
- Let your attorney lead: Your attorney knows the hearing procedures and will guide the presentation of your case. Follow their lead.
- Do not volunteer information: Answer questions directly and concisely. Do not offer additional information that was not asked for.
After the Hearing
The hearing officer will typically issue a decision within 30 days. If the decision is unfavorable, you have the right to request a departmental review or file a writ of mandate in superior court. Your attorney can advise you on the best course of action based on the specific circumstances of your case.
Preparation is the single most important factor in winning a DMV hearing. If you are facing an administrative hearing and want to give yourself the best possible chance of keeping your license, contact Law Office of Rodney Gould for a free consultation today.
Rodney Gould
Based in Sherman Oaks, California, Law Office of Rodney Gould is led by attorney Rodney Gould, who has been practicing law since 1991. Though he started as a civil prosecutor working for the United States Postal Service on mail fraud cases in Washington, D.C., his career has developed over the years to include litigation experience in federal courts across the United States, serving as a special assistant U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia with the Department of Justice and, after leaving the government sector, providing legal services to some of the nation’s largest companies such as Starbucks, MCI, USAA and Bank of America.
Author's Bio